YouTube vs Netflix in Streaming TV: How the Battle Is Shaping Global Viewing Habits

For years, Netflix treated the idea of competition as an abstraction. Its co-founder Reed Hastings once said sleep was the real rival. But that era of untouchable dominance is over.

In 2025, it’s no longer just about gaining subscribers. It’s about controlling screen time, and YouTube is winning that war.

According to Nielsen, YouTube now commands 12.5% of U.S. television viewing, compared to Netflix’s 7.5%. That’s not just more than Netflix — it’s more than Disney, Amazon, HBO Max, Peacock, and Paramount+ combined.

This isn’t a fluke. Two years ago, YouTube barely edged ahead of Netflix in TV viewership. Now it leads by a full five percentage points. And it’s not just in the U.S.—the shift is visible in mobile-first markets like Kenya, where YouTube’s open platform and zero-data bundles (often subsidized by telcos) have made it the default TV.

The Rise of AVOD: Free Is the New Premium

Streaming is still growing overall — by 6% year-over-year — but paid services like Netflix and Disney+ are flatlining in viewership share. The real growth is happening in free, ad-supported services like YouTube, Tubi, and The Roku Channel.

For younger users, especially in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, ad-supported streaming is native behavior, not a compromise. And that’s shifting the economics of the entertainment business globally.

Netflix, built on a subscription model, is adapting. Nearly half of its U.S. signups now choose the ad-supported tier, and it’s investing cautiously in live sports and short-form content to compete.

Netflix Still Has Hits — But They’re No Longer Enough

Make no mistake — Netflix still knows how to dominate the cultural moment. In the first half of 2025, Squid Game’s second and third seasons ranked among the most-watched globally. Three of Netflix’s series landed in Nielsen’s top four most-viewed titles.

But the broader trend tells a different story.

Back in 2021, Netflix commanded over 80% of top streaming titles. Today, that’s down to just under 50%, with Amazon, Apple, HBO, Hulu, and Paramount+ closing the gap.

Amazon’s Reacher, Jack Ryan, and The Boys confirm the enduring popularity of action-driven content. HBO’s The Last of Us and White Lotus would also crack the Top 10 — if not for Nielsen classifying them as “acquired” due to linear broadcast.

It’s not that Netflix has fallen. It’s that everyone else has caught up.

YouTube’s Creator Advantage — and Netflix’s Envy

While Netflix pays creators upfront and controls content from pitch to playback, YouTube lets creators upload what they want, when they want, and shares ad revenue instead of covering production costs.

That model has created breakout stars who are now crossing over into Netflix’s world. Ms. Rachel, a YouTube-native kids’ creator, is now a Netflix sensation. Her repackaged videos have appeared in Netflix’s Top 10 23 times in 2025.

Netflix has also licensed or entered talks with YouTube megastars like the Sidemen, Dude Perfect, and Mark Rober.

Netflix executives insist they’re offering creators a “promotion” to the big leagues. As Ted Sarandos put it, YouTube is a “farm league” where creators “cut their teeth.” But YouTube CEO Neal Mohan clapped back, saying viewers decide how to spend their time — and that Ms. Rachel’s fans likely don’t think they’re slumming it.

Reruns, Routines, and the Power of Familiarity

Hulu remains the king of reruns. Seven of the top 10 “acquired” titles stream on Hulu, with Grey’s Anatomy leading the pack. Netflix also benefits from rerun content like Peppa Pig and Gabby’s Dollhouse.

This trend confirms something tech platforms have long understood: users crave convenience and comfort. In a fragmented attention economy, habit is currency.

In Kenya and other emerging markets, YouTube thrives on this logic. With zero-cost access, algorithmically perfect recommendations, and wide local content variety, it fills every gap in a viewer’s day — whether it’s five minutes on a matatu or a family evening in front of a smart TV.

Theaters Aren’t Dead — Yet

While global box office revenue is up 8% this year, it’s still down 27% from pre-pandemic highs. Marvel’s Thunderbolts and Brave New World underperformed, and even hits like Superman aren’t what they used to be.

Yet there’s a twist: the two most-watched streaming movies of 2025 — Moana 2 and Despicable Me 4 — both debuted in theaters. Theatrical release still builds buzz, awareness, and brand value that translates into digital success.

Netflix, which once wanted to bypass cinemas entirely, is now realizing that theaters are a powerful marketing funnel — even if they’re not the endgame.

Netflix vs YouTube: A Tale of Two Tech Titans

At its core, this rivalry is a battle between closed and open ecosystems.

Netflix curates its content, controls the flow, and treats creators as contractors.

YouTube lets creators publish directly, leverages user data, and runs a nearly infinite content loop.

Netflix’s advantage is polish and prestige. YouTube’s is scale, relevance, and data-driven precision.

As ex-Hulu CEO Jason Kilar said: “When you open YouTube, you get a far more surgical presentation of things to entertain you than you ever will from a traditional streamer.”

The Audience Is King

The old adage said, content is king. In 2025, it’s the audience that rules.

YouTube was a platform that became a studio. Netflix was a studio that became a platform. Both now compete for the same thing: time — and the trust that comes with it.

For creators in Kenya, the implications are clear:

You no longer need to knock on Hollywood’s door. Whether you’re uploading vlogs from Nyeri, kids’ songs from Kisumu, or game shows filmed in Nairobi, YouTube offers the path. And now, Netflix may come knocking.

The streaming war isn’t just global. It’s hyperlocal — and it’s already playing out on your screen.

Mark your calendars! TechTrends Pulse lands in Nairobi this August! Join top tech leaders, innovators & AI experts for a half-day of keynotes, showcases & sharp insights on business transformation. RSVP now -limited slots available! Register here.

Follow us on WhatsApp, Telegram, Twitter, and Facebook, or subscribe to our weekly newsletter to ensure you don’t miss out on any future updates. Send tips to editorial@techtrendsmedia.co.ke